Instant Pot Homemade Rolo Yoghurt

This Post Contains Affiliate Links. Click Here To Read Our Full Disclosure.

Introducing you to homemade rolo yoghurt in the instant pot. The best tasting instant pot yoghurt you will ever try. Only four simple ingredients are needed, and you will be making this caramel yoghurt time and time again.

If you love Rolo’s then you will love how to add them to your latest batch of instant pot cold start yoghurt.  

This is an updated post. We originally shared with you all about the instant pot rolo yoghurt back in early 2017.

instant pot rolo yoghurt recipe
Instant Pot Rolo Yoghurt Recipe

Rolo Yoghurt

I never buy flavoured yoghurts from the supermarket. I find them too expensive and would much rather buy a big tub of Greek yoghurt or natural yoghurt and then add flavours to it.

The kids favourite now, is Greek yoghurt from Aldi (their fat free Greek tastes amazing!) and then they will have it with some food colouring, and some sprinkles.

They love mixing and matching the food colouring and it ends up like our rainbow ice cream recipe.

Or in summer if we have some spare fruit, we will add the yoghurt to some strawberries and make a yummy strawberry yoghurt.

The rolo yoghurt idea came about, because we were living in Portugal, and it was the only flavoured yoghurt I ever bought.

I bought it because it was my favourite and only ever if it was on reduced price because it was near its use by date. Of course, this didn’t happen very often and instead I wanted to make my own.

Our instant pot Greek yoghurt meets Rolos and toffee sauce to make this delicious chocolately yoghurt.

Are You New To The Instant Pot?

instant pot mini course reusable block

Plus, as well as our extremely popular instant pot mini course which teaches you the instant pot basics in 5 days, we also have our instant pot bucket list. That is loaded with 30 FREE bucket list worthy instant pot recipes.

Click here or on the banner above and you will have access to both in an instant.

Are Rolo Yoghurts Gluten Free?

The rolo yoghurt ingredients that we use to make the yoghurt with are gluten free. Such as Greek yoghurt, milk and sauce.

And the rolo chocolate that we added is also gluten free.

What Is A Rolo Yoghurt?

For those of you that live outside of the UK and don’t get the obsession with a rolo yoghurt, then note its one of the best tasting yoghurts ever.

Featuring chocolate and caramel like in a packet of rolos and then with a really creamy yoghurt.

Our version uses toffee sauce + homemade instant pot yoghurt + mixed in rolls of rolos.

The Yoghurt For Yoghurt Haters

I also consider this rolo yoghurt recipe to be the yoghurt for yoghurt haters. Most people that hate yoghurt do so because all the additives in yoghurt.

Then they try real homemade yoghurt, and they are shocked by how delicious it actually is.

If in doubt, try the instant pot Greek yoghurt first then add in extras and see what you think.

Why Yoghurt Is Good For You?

Yoghurt is good for you because it is high in protein, fills you up and is a good source of calcium and other vitamins.

However, not all yoghurts are created equal and if you want healthy yoghurt go with plain Greek yoghurt.

Which Yoghurt Is Healthy?

One that you make yourself. Nothing is going to be more healthy than your own homemade yoghurt.

Often when you look on the ingredients of yoghurts, you will see ingredients you can not understand, that are needed to make the yoghurt longer lasting.

By making your own yoghurt like we show you in our instant pot yoghurt setting guide, you can strip it of these extras and just use plain Greek yoghurt and milk.

Would you like easy & amazing instant pot recipes from instant pot experts? Click here and join the Recipe This Newsletter. We will then send you the BEST instant pot beginner recipes direct to your email inbox along with other useful instant pot resources.

Rolo Yoghurt Ingredients

Yoghurt – You will need a tablespoon of shop bought yoghurt to make homemade yoghurt with. Any with active cultures is fine and I prefer the Fage Greek yoghurt.

Milk – The second essential ingredient for making this rolo yoghurt recipe is some milk. You can also swap out 1 cup of it for sweetened condensed milk to make it even sweeter.

Sauce – I also recommend some sauce that you can pour into your yoghurt such as toffee sauce or caramel sauce. We used M&S toffee sauce.

Rolos – You will also want plenty of rolos that you can add into the yoghurt. You can crunch them up and add them or melt them and then stir in once cool.

Whisk – You’re also going to need a silicone whisk that you can use in the instant pot to whisk up the milk and yoghurt ahead of hitting the yoghurt setting.

Then for the kitchen gadgets that we have used in this rolo yoghurt recipe it has just been our Instant Pot. We have this one and it’s my favourite and great for a lot of foods that can make from scratch.

Plus, we recommend you head over to our instant pot recipes category as we have many electric pressure cooker recipes and have been using instant pots for 5 years.

How To Make Rolo Yoghurt?

instant pot rolo yoghurt step by step
  • Prepare. Start by completing the instant pot water test. It’s a fantastic way for a thorough sterilisation of your instant pot before making the yoghurt.
  • Load. Then load up your instant pot with the yoghurt along with a cup of milk. Then use your whisk to mix the milk into the yoghurt.
  • Gradually. Then gradually add the rest of the milk and whisk until you have milk bubbles.
  • Cook. Place the lid on the instant pot, set it to yoghurt and leave the yoghurt to cook in the instant pot for 8 hours.
  • Fridge. Then when it beeps, place the yoghurt in the fridge overnight.
  • Strain. The next day after it has been in the fridge overnight, strain and then serve.
  • Finish. Then add to your yoghurt some caramel or toffee sauce as well as crushed rolos before serving.

And I am sure you can see now how simple and easy it is to make our instant pot rolo yoghurt recipe.

My Instant Pot Yoghurt

My Instant Pot Yoghurt

This rolo yoghurt recipe, was done during a big batch of a range of different instant pot yoghurts. We did Greek yoghurt, natural yoghurt, then condensed milk yoghurt as well as some with strawberries and a few other flavours.

This rolo yoghurt was our favourite, and the one that was gone fastest from the fridge.

Rolo Yoghurt Tips & Tricks

  • Don’t skip the straining step. It removes any excess water and makes your yoghurt extra creamy so that you would think it was high fat.
  • Want a higher fat Greek yoghurt? Then swap 5% fat for full fat yoghurt and use whole milk (full fat milk) instead of semi skimmed.
  • You can store leftover yoghurt in plastic mason jars and then store them in the fridge. We use these ones.
  • Make sure you whisk your milk and yoghurt together. It will make a much better yoghurt and will be light and creamy.
  • Put the yoghurt on in early afternoon (about 2pm), then it will be ready for placing in the fridge at 10pm before bed, then cool overnight in the fridge and its ready for straining from 8am.
  • Strain your yoghurt by placing kitchen towel over a sieve and pouring through.

Plus, check out our instant pot yoghurt setting guide which goes into a much more detail.

More Instant Pot Recipes From Scratch

instant pot rolo yoghurt

Your rolo yoghurt recipe is below, note you can print it out with or without photos, adjust servings, or click between metric and imperial depending on where you are in the world.

Though before you do, don’t forget to subscribe, and grab your FREE VIP Pass to Recipe This. You will get access to our latest recipes first, you will be able to request recipes, you will have access to free mini courses, free instant pot ebooks and useful instant pot cook time charts and so much more.

instant pot rolo yoghurt
Print Recipe
5 from 1 vote

Instant Pot Homemade Rolo Yoghurt

Introducing you to homemade rolo yoghurt in the instant pot. The best tasting instant pot yoghurt you will ever try. Only four simple ingredients are needed, and you will be making this caramel yoghurt time and time again.
Prep Time5 minutes
Cook Time8 hours
Total Time8 hours 5 minutes
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: Instant Pot
Servings: 2 Jars
Calories: 684kcal



  • Perform the instant pot water test first.
    How To Make Rolo Yoghurt?
  • Load your yogurt into the instant pot along with 1/8 of the milk. Whisk until well mixed and starting to froth.
    How To Make Rolo Yoghurt?
  • Pour in the rest of the milk and whisk until frothy like milk from a coffee shop.
    How To Make Rolo Yoghurt?
  • Place the lid on the instant pot and no need to set to sealing. Press the yogurt setting and make sure the time is set to 8 hours, if not press the + or – until you have 8 hours and then press start.
    How To Make Rolo Yoghurt?
  • After 8 hours and it has beeped, remove from the instant pot, and make sure you don’t stir. Then cover with its silicone lid and place in the fridge for a further 8 hours to chill.
    How To Make Rolo Yoghurt?
  • Place a colander over a bowl and then add kitchen towel. Then pour your yoghurt over the kitchen towel. Then leave it for an hour for the excess water to drain away from the yoghurt.
    How To Make Rolo Yoghurt?
  • After it has chilled and been strained, stir and load ¼ of your yogurt into a bowl and mix it up with 2 packets of crushed rolos and ½ the toffee sauce.
    How To Make Rolo Yoghurt?
  • In your yogurt jar add swirls of the toffee sauce around the edges like you are making a homemade McFlurry and then add in your stirred rolo yogurt. Load into the fridge and chill for an extra 30 minutes before serving.
    How To Make Rolo Yoghurt?


Quantities. I have listed this recipe as a quantity of 2 and that is because it fills 1 jar and is plenty for two.
Swaps. You can do the same and then swap rolo chocolate for any favourite chocolate and sauce combination.
Silicone. It’s essential that you use a silicone whisk because otherwise it will damage the instant pot inner pot.
Thanks for reading our instant pot rolo yogurt recipe on Recipe This. We have many more instant pot recipes for you to check out next. Though if you would like to see more instant pot recipes from scratch, I recommend you try our instant pot veggie stock next.


Calories: 684kcal | Carbohydrates: 60g | Protein: 34g | Fat: 35g | Saturated Fat: 20g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 1g | Monounsaturated Fat: 8g | Cholesterol: 123mg | Sodium: 458mg | Potassium: 1585mg | Fiber: 1g | Sugar: 56g | Vitamin A: 1640IU | Vitamin C: 1mg | Calcium: 1264mg | Iron: 1mg
Nutrition InfoPlease Note: Nutrition values are our best estimate based on the software we use at Recipe This and are meant as a guide. If you rely on them for your diet, use your preferred nutrition calculator.
Have You Tried The Instant Pot Mini Course?Its FREE and its delivered by email over 5 days. Ideal for beginners to the instant pot Click Here.
Are We Friends On Pinterest?If we are not and you use Pinterest then follow us @RecipeThisBlog for more delicious recipes.
Fancy A Video?Subscribe to the Recipe This YouTube Channel for full length recipe videos. Don’t forget to click the bell icon to be notified when we upload a new video. Subscribe Here!
Copyright Notice© ALL content including photos are copyright protected. Sharing of our recipes is both encouraged and appreciated via the social share buttons. Copying and/or pasting full recipes to any social media channel or onto your own website is strictly prohibited.

Can’t make it now? Then save it for later!

Recipe This

Hi! I am Sam and along with my chef hubby Dom we love sharing with you easy everyday recipes using kitchen gadgets. We are also the authors of The Complete Air Fryer Cookbook, an amazing air fryer cookbook filled with 140+ everyday air fryer recipes. Beyond the air fryer we also love the instant pot, slow cooker, soup maker, ninja foodi, pie marker and several other kitchen gadgets. CLICKING HERE →

1 thought on “Instant Pot Homemade Rolo Yoghurt”

  1. 5 stars
    I tried this using some chocolate beans as we do not have the toffee rolo things you mention in the post. It was so delicious and my kids think i bought it from the shop, that is how good it tastes.


Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating