Copycat Banana & Custard Muller Light Yoghurt

"Here is our copycat muller light banana and custard recipe."

Welcome to my copycat banana and custard Muller Light yoghurt recipe in the blender.

I have had Muller Light yoghurts for years. They became the everyday staple of the British dieter or people that just like nice low fat yoghurts. This was long before Paleo was popular and if you were to snack back then you would have had a Muller Light in your hand.

I partly believe the partnership that Slimming World had with the Muller Light brand that made it so popular. If you were on Slimming World you had Muller Lights simply because you could have as many of them as you wanted and these lovely big delicious yoghurts were less than 100 calories a pot.

We used to buy them from the supermarket and back then at the beginning of the 00’s you would pay just £1 for five of them. Compare this to todays prices here in Portugal where we pay approximately 1,20€ per yoghurt they no longer seem like the same low cost snack that they once where.

Dominic used to love the banana and custard variety where as my favourite was always the toffee version. Actually, I remember when Kyle was a baby having them in hospital to keep me going through the breastfeeding moments during the night. He is going to be 15 next month, so this just shows how long I have enjoyed them for.

But since being against low fat eating and wanting to follow a more natural way of life without anything artificial in my diet I have quit the Muller Light yoghurts and instead prefer to make my own with some Greek Yoghurt and not only do I enjoy them made from scratch but so do the kids.

Dominic was making a small yoghurt for Sofia for her lunch a couple of months ago and said how much it reminded him of the banana and custard Muller Light yoghurt. I had a try and I was suddenly hooked. And this recipe is the exact same one we made by accident and it is so much healthier and natural and is so much cheaper to make.

After making this a few months ago we have not bought another flavoured yoghurt since and would rather make them ourselves.

[Tweet “#Copycat #Banana & #Custard Muller Light Yoghurt Via recipe_this”]

Copycat Banana & Custard Muller Light Yoghurt
Serves: 1 large yoghurt pot
Prep time:
Total time:
  • 3Tbsp Greek Yoghurt
  • 1 Medium Banana
  • ⅕Tsp Vanilla Extract
  • 1Tsp Maple Syrup
  1. Slice your banana into small chunks.
  2. Add your banana, yoghurt, vanilla extract, and maple syrup into your blender and blend until smooth.
  3. Serve.
You could also alter this and work your way through the full Muller Light collection. We particularly love recreating the fruity ones with fresh strawberries.

I also find that honey works as a great alternative to maple syrup.

copycat small ecoverDo You Want MORE? Get Another 20 Recipes:

We have put together 21 favourite copycat recipes into one amazing cookery ebook. It features all our favourite copycat recipes from your favourite fast food establishments along with a lot of processed food classics. Learn how to make all those unhealthy meals in a much healthier way.

We even have 5 recipes dedicated to KFC and discover how to make their secret seasoning mix yourself. You could now have a KFC at home without worrying about the weight gain or the expense!

This ebook is just $2.99 on the Kindle and you can get your hands on it by clicking here.

"Here is the ingredients we used to create our copycat muller light banana and custard yoghurt."

Meet The Milners

Samantha and Dominic

Dominic & Samantha Milner are the founders of They love cooking, blogging and being full time parents to their three food obsessed kids. They cook with their kitchen gadgets everyday and love sharing their homemade recipes. Their favourite foods include chocolate, air fryer burgers and macaroni cheese. You can learn more about them here or you can sign up for their free newsletter here.

0 comments… add one

Leave a Comment

Rate this recipe: